PSA Standardization

Effect on "Watchful Waiting"

October 2009

Visually we can see this difference again in the figure shown.  After some amount of time a man’s PSA becomes elevated or greater than the 4.0 ng/mL cutoff with a Hybritech assay. Using that same cutoff in a WHO standardized assay, the PSA is now less than 4.0 ng/mL or may be considered “normal”.  After some period of time, perhaps an abnormal result would be obtained but if the increase in PSA is due to cancer there is a greater risk in increasing the stage and grade of prostate cancer with the watchful waiting approach.

< Previous Slide

Watchful Waiting

Next Slide >

 

Jump to section:

• Introduction
• Elevated PSA Result on Screening
• Reasons for Ordering PSA¹
• PSA Screening in the News
• Recommendations for Screening
• Arguments for Screening for Prostate Cancer
• Recommendations for Not Screening
• Arguments Against Screening for Prostate Cancer
• PSA Sensitivity and Specificity
• High-Grade Prostate Cancer is Not Rare When PSA =4.0 ng/mL⁶
• Increase Specificity Using PSA Velocity⁸
• Optimizing Clinical Sensitivity and Specificity: Age/Ethnic Reference Intervals^9,10
• Utilization of Free/Total PSA Ratio¹¹
• Why Aren't PSA Results Interchangeable?
• Development of PSA Standards
• Development of PSA Standards
• Effect of Analytical Bias on Classification Based on Fixed Criteria
• Analytical Difference: Results per 1000 Patients Tested¹³
• Hybritech vs. WHO Standardized Assays^12,14
• Analytical Differences¹⁵
• CAP Proficiency Testing
• WHO 96/670 Total PSA Preparations¹⁶
• WHO Calibration/Concordance at 3.1 ng/mL Cutoff⁵
• WHO Calibration/Concordance at 3.1 ng/mL Cutoff⁵
• WHO Calibration/Concordance at 4.0 ng/mL Cutoff⁵
• Clinical Differences in PSA Screening¹⁴
• The Clinical Difference
• Fixed Thresholds Produce Problems for Biopsy Recommendations
• Effect on "Watchful Waiting"
• Effect on "Watchful Waiting"
• Adding Biological Variability into the Mix
• Futures in Prostate Cancer Testing?
• PSA Testing at Mayo
• Conclusions
• References
• References
• Questions?